No commit message

No commit message

BMC_jvenn/bmc_jvenn.tex

@@ -516,20 +516,22 @@ reviewers for their insightful and constructive comments.
 		& input lists & & & & & \\ \hline
 		
 		VENNTURE \cite{Bronwen2012} &  6 & Edwards & Stand-alone & No & Lists &
-		Powerpoint,\\ 
-		& & & & & & Excel, CSV \\ \hline
+		Powerpoint\\ 
+		& & & & & & and Excel \\ \hline
 		
 		VennDiagram \cite{RVennDiagram} &  5 & Classical & R package & No & Lists
-		& R object, TIFF \\ \hline
+		& R object \\
+		& & & & & & and TIFF \\ \hline
 		
 		BioVenn \cite{Hulsen2008} &  3 & Classical & Web application & Yes &
-		Lists & SVG, PNG \\ \hline
+		Lists & SVG and PNG \\ \hline
 		
 		venny \cite{venny} &  4 & Classical & Web application & No &
 		Lists & PNG \\ \hline
 		 
 		Canvasxpress \cite{canvasxpress} &  4 & Classical & JavaScript library &
-		No & Intersection counts & JavaScript canvas \\ \hline
+		No & Intersection & JavaScript \\
+		& & & & & counts & canvas \\ \hline
 		
 		Google & 3 & Classical & JavaScript library &
 		Yes & Lists & PNG \\ 
@@ -538,8 +540,9 @@ reviewers for their insightful and constructive comments.
 		jvenn & 6 & Classical & Web application & No & Lists,
 		& Interactive 
 		\\
-		& & and Edwards & and JavaScript library & & intersection counts & diagram, \\
-		& & & & & and count lists & PNG, CSV
+		& & and Edwards & and JavaScript & & intersection & diagram, \\
+		& & & library & & counts and & PNG and CSV \\
+		& & & & & count lists & 
 	\end{tabular}
 \end{table}
 

BMC_jvenn/jvenn_coverletter_bis.tex

@@ -115,7 +115,13 @@ not  any of the other lists. How did the papers (10,11) use it and why couldn't
 they use another library? Perhaps a brief mention of other ways to
 look/visualize this data might be worth it:}
 
-
+The organisation of the manuscript has been modified and several paragraph have
+been rewritten. 
+The two papers citing jvenn used it to built a publishable diagram. They used
+jvenn because it is the only Web application available allowing users to provide
+5 lists. To produce such a diagram they could have use VENNTURE as well, but
+this application is only available under MS-Windows and only produce Powerpoint
+outputs under the Edwards-Venn layout.
 
 \textbf{-- Reviewer 2 --}
 
@@ -158,10 +164,8 @@ sets of items. A clear statement about the novel contributions (with
 respect to the library) will strengthen the paper.}
 
 jvenn is only using the venny algorithm to compute the lists intersection.
-The sentence ``jvenn intersection computing algorithm is based on venny.
-The algorithm has been wrapped in a jQuery plug-in,
-extended with new features presented hereunder and the ability to use up to six
-lists.'' has been added as introduction to the Implementation section.
+The sentence ``jvenn intersection computing algorithm is based on venny.'' has 
+been added to the Implementation section.
 
 
 \textbf{4. The authors should describe the three different data formats.